

For the sixth edition of the Rate the Raters study, the ERM Sustainability Institute surveyed 53 investment professionals, whose organisations represent approximately $23.5 trillion in assets under management, between February and July 2026. Ten interviews complemented the survey. The first key finding is that ESG ratings remain very prevalent: 58% of respondents use them at least once a week.
However, their role in the analysis process is changing. When asked about the most useful sources of information for their decisions, investors cited their in-house research first (54%), followed by direct dialogue with companies (50%) and sustainability reports (40%). Ratings and data from providers fit into this framework, with 33% citing data from third-party providers and 31% citing the ratings themselves.
The level of trust placed in ratings is following a similar trend. It stands at an average of 3.05 out of 5, down from 3.31 in 2023. Half of the respondents rated them at 3, and a quarter at 2. However, this finding should be interpreted with caution: the panel has grown from 33 to 53 respondents, becoming more international and more diverse in terms of profiles, an expansion which the report itself cites as one of the explanatory factors. This shift undoubtedly reflects investors taking a closer look at what they are using, whilst continuing to make use of it.
The interviews highlight the value that data providers bring. An American asset manager explains that their offering covers more than 15,000 issuers and extends analysis to other asset classes, from sovereign bonds to securitised assets. Another believes it is better to rely on these experts, who ensure quality control, adapt the data for operational use and match it to company and security identifiers.
In terms of perceived quality, the highest-rated providers are awarded scores ranging from 3.41 to 3.50 out of 5. The report suggests that these rankings reflect their strong market recognition and their integration into fund managers’ workflows.
Investors often work with several providers: 44% use between three and five. They supplement this foundation with specialised sources, particularly on climate transition plans, biodiversity, nature, human rights and geospatial analysis. The interviews highlight the value of collaborating with smaller players on these specific topics.
The rationale is one of complementarity: a broad foundation of coverage, enriched by thematic insights. This shifts the focus from the selection of providers to the integration of their data – that is, how to reconcile, compare and link them within a single analytical process.
Public sources are also gaining in importance. The proportion of investors citing the media as one of their most useful sources rises from 3% to 13% between 2023 and 2026, whilst the proportion citing information filed with market regulators rises from 0% to 10%.
When investors are asked what determines the quality and usefulness of a rating, methodology tops the list: 93% consider it important that the methodology is published, whilst 91% consider it important that it is of high quality.
This requirement stems in part from the nature of the ratings. An ESG score is the quantification of an analysis that remains, to a large extent, qualitative: assessing the credibility of a transition plan is a matter of judgement rather than a mere figure. Investors therefore rely on analyses already structured by providers – including to build their own proprietary ratings – and need to understand how they are constructed in order to use them.
The priorities set out for the next five years point in the same direction. Investors prioritise a greater focus on material issues, followed by a closer link to financial performance, but also call for more transparent methodologies.
The regulatory framework supports this trend. The European regulation on ESG ratings has been in force since July 2026 and places providers under the supervision of ESMA (the European Securities and Markets Authority), with requirements regarding governance, transparency and the publication of methodologies. The report estimates that established providers already have the necessary governance and compliance infrastructure in place, and that this framework aims to strengthen the comparability and credibility of the market as a whole.
It is within this context that WeeFin’s Methodology Lab approach fits. Data from providers forms the raw material. The Lab enables this data to be standardised, weighted according to the investor’s choice, and allows a documented order of priority to be defined amongst multiple sources when data is missing from one of them; it also enables the result to be compared with a provider’s rating and each step of the calculation to be traced, issuer by issuer.
This approach addresses several use cases described by the investors surveyed. In the survey, 38.5% collect the underlying data from ratings to feed into their own models. A proprietary methodology also ensures continuity over time: when a provider updates its model – which is part of normal market operations – an in-house assessment framework retains its interpretation rules and exclusions.
The case of transition plans illustrates this logic. No single source covers all the criteria an investor wishes to examine. An assessment grid built from several specialised datasets, with explicit weightings, enables investors to formalise their own judgement and explain it to their clients or risk committee. The same reasoning applies to the integration of public sources – from the media to regulatory filings – alongside data from providers.
This approach is in line with a recommendation in the report to providers: to make the underlying data more accessible and flexible, in order to support the growing use of proprietary research and models. It highlights the importance of the quality of the source data, since the robustness of an internal methodology depends on that of the sources and intermediate scoring methodologies feeding into it.
The challenge lies not so much in collecting information as in scaling up the process: producing internal scores and deploying them on a large scale. The more the analysis is internalised, the more important it becomes to document the methodology underpinning it and to make it traceable. It remains to be seen how investors, providers and platforms will jointly build this value chain.
Main source: ERM Sustainability Institute, Rate the Raters 2026: Beyond the score (October 2026).